|

How to Find a Great Cover Designer 

And a Guide for Vetting Them

Guest Post by Dario Villirilli 

If you want readers to buy your book you need a proper cover. Which is why choosing a cover designer might be one of the most consequential decisions in your self-publishing journey. But where do you find the right one for your book? And how do you vet them before handing over a deposit?

We’ll walk through all of it: where to find legitimate designers, how to shortlist and vet the ones worth talking to, and what a solid brief and contract look like once you’re ready to hire.

Look for designers in the right places

Start with good ol’ word of mouth. Ask your author friends (ideally in your genre) if they know someone. Alternatively, you can also check the copyright pages and acknowledgements of independently published books you admire, and reach out directly to the credited artists.

But most likely, you will find it by browsing a professional marketplace or directory like Reedsy. It’s a lot easier to compare portfolios, experience, services, availability, and client reviews in one place. You may also find designers through freelance illustrator communities (think Reddit, Instagram, ArtStation, Behance) 

General freelance platforms such as Fiverr and Upwork can also be useful, but they require more careful screening: anyone can call themselves a cover designer, regardless of their experience or track record.

Shortlist designers whose work fits your book

Once you find a great marketplace with plenty of profiles, build a shortlist of three to five designers in your genre. As you look through their work, ask yourself:

  • Can you distinguish a thriller from a romance, or a memoir from a self-help book? 
  • How much experience do they have in your genre? (A designer with several covers in your niche is likely to be a better fit than one with a single beautiful but unrelated project.)
  • Do the covers work as thumbnails as well?

Versatility is another encouraging sign. A designer may have a recognizable style, but the strongest portfolios show they can approach very different books in different ways. For example, Barış Şehri’s work has a soulful, bold style, yet each concept feels distinct.

Published titles, recognizable clients, awards, and years of professional experience can all help establish a designer’s credibility. Client reviews are equally revealing. Look for comments on their communication, punctuality, approach to feedback, and whether they delivered the correct final files. Try to understand what it is actually like to work with them before reaching out.

Send a useful brief and compare the responses

Once you have a shortlist, contact each designer with the same core information. Your design brief should include:

  • A concise synopsis and description of the target reader
  • Genre, subgenre, and two or three comparable titles
  • The book’s tone, themes, setting, and key imagery
  • Covers you like, with a short explanation of why
  • Any ideas or elements you want to avoid
  • Required formats, trim size, and publishing platform (if you know that)
  • Your deadline and budget range
  • Whether the book is part of a planned series

You can also attach the manuscript or a substantial sample. Some designers prefer to read the whole book; others work from your brief and synopsis, then tell you what they need. 

In all cases, pay attention to how each designer replies. Do they respond thoughtfully to the book, or simply send a price? Are they willing to challenge an idea that may not serve the market? The wisest designers will consider both what you want and what you need. 😉

4. Vet the process before you hire

Before accepting an offer, don’t be afraid to ask whatever questions are on your mind. For instance, about their process:

  • How many initial directions will they present? 
  • At what stages can you offer feedback?
  • How many revisions are included? 
  • What files will you receive, exactly? 

It’s also completely reasonable to ask whether generative AI tools will be used. Some designers use it for ideation, others in production too, and some don’t touch it at all. Whatever your preference, discuss it before the project begins.

There’s no single right way to run a cover-design project. What matters is that the stages are clear, and that you have meaningful opportunities to respond before too much time is spent pursuing the wrong direction. 

When making your final choice, consider the whole picture: portfolio fit, relevant experience, thoughtfulness, communication, availability, process, and price. Take your time to find the right person for the job, and you will be far more likely to end up with a cover that feels true to your book — and makes the right readers want to open it.

Dario Villirilli is a writer with Reedsy, a marketplace that connects authors with self-publishing resources and professionals like editors, designers, and ghostwriters.

Image Courtesy of Pexels

Other Posts You Might Like

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *